The question of why Abby killed Joel in The Last of Us Part II is one of the most talked-about topics in gaming. It sparks passionate debate among fans because the answer cuts deeper than a simple revenge story. Exploring this moment helps players understand the game's themes of empathy, moral gray areas, and the true cost of violence—not just in fictional worlds, but in how we perceive real-life conflicts as well.
To put things simply, Abby's motivation was rooted in her father's death. Joel killed her father, a Firefly surgeon, while saving Ellie in the first game. That surgeon was about to perform the procedure to develop a cure for the zombie infection before Joel interrupted. Abby grew up with that loss hanging over her, and she spent years training her body and waiting for the chance to avenge him.
When Abby finally finds Joel, she doesn't hesitate. She uses a golf club to beat him to death, making the scene deliberately brutal. This is where the game's genius lies: it forces Ellie—and the player—to confront someone who sees Joel as a villain, not the hero we cheered for in Part One. It reframes the entire narrative around perspective.
Must Read
Common variations fans debate include whether Abby was justified or whether the scene was excessively violent. Some argue she mirrors Joel's own tendency toward ruthless survival, creating a chilling parallel between the two characters. The real lesson is that every person in The Last of Us believes they are doing the right thing for the people they love.
PlayStation (PS5) News & Rumors | The Direct
To get the most out of this discussion, play (or replay) both games back-to-back and pay close attention to how each character motivates their choices. Listen to the dialogue rather than rushing through gameplay. Consider writing down your reactions after each game to track how your perspective shifts.
Ultimately, Abby killed Joel because grief and the desire for justice consumed her. The story reminds us that revenge rarely brings peace—it just starts a new cycle of pain. Understanding that collision of motives is what makes The Last of Us unforgettable.
