How Old Was The Cast Of Pll In Season 1

So you just binged all seven seasons of Pretty Little Liars and now you're wondering — how old were these "teenagers" actually playing high schoolers? Buckle up, because some of these ages are going to make you feel like an overripe banana.

The Liars Themselves

Let's start with Troian Bellisario, who played the perfectionist Spencer. At Season 1, she was 28 years old, which means she was basically old enough to actually be a student's mother. The woman could have been on the PTA instead of suspecting being harassed by "A" every five minutes.

Shay Mitchell, our lovable Emily, was 26 at the time. So yes, a 26-year-old woman was crying, swimming, and having identity crises in a high school pool. Very normal stuff. Very. Normal.

Lucy Hale, the tiny fiery Aria who probably had ✨collage✨ on her wall, was 22 years old. She's the closest one to actual teen age, but still old enough to legally buy a drink. Our secret admirer Ezra should've checked IDs.

And then there's Ashley Benson, playing Hanna the fashionista who never looked like she missed a meal unless "A" forced her. She was 22 as well. Honestly, between her and Lucy, they were the invite CDIrons of the group — almost believable as teens.

Who Is A In Pretty Little Liars Tv Show – MLLOWV

The Guys Who Were Supposed to Be Struggling Youths

Keegan Allen, the brooding Toby driver, was 23. So imagine a 23-year-old man quietly building cabins in the woods while pretending to be a brooding teen. Respect the hustle. He also kept his poker face better than most Gen restaurant owners.

Tyler Blackburn, playing the dreamy Caleb, came in at 25. That's a quarter of a century, people. A 25-year-old hacker wrapping a BLEAT around Hannah in a high school hallway. At least he looked youthful about it.

How Old Was The Cast Of Pll In Season 1 | TAFT Independent

The Teachers Who Were Almost the Same Age as Their Students

Janel Parrish, Mona's terrifying double life, was 24 while pretending to be a high school junior. But then Wren Brown — should I say Wren's teacher? — Nope, the real teacher was Ian Harding? Actually, the real hit was that ICA Hardy was PAUL Deane old. I mean, try again.

Meanwhile, Ian Harding, who played the suspicious English teacher Ezra, was 35 years old. A 35-year-old man falling in love with a 16-year-old. Even the fictional world thought that was fine? We had questions. Many, many questions.

Pretty Little Liars Season 1 Photoshoot

So What Have We Learned?

That Hollywood will slather a 34-year-old in a baseball cap and call it "teenage years," and we will absolutely buy it — especially when the plot is stolen love letters and masked figures. The only more surprising discovery is that everyone got age charts wrong.

Next time you rewatch Pretty Little Liars, just quietly chant "they're actually old enough to rent a car" every time they walk into homeroom. It changes the whole experience. Trust me on this one.