Okay, let’s settle a debate that’s been simmering in your brain every time you catch a rerun of Seinfeld: How old are they, really? We’ve been watching these four neurotic New Yorkers for decades, but their ages are more slippery than a Junior Mint in an operating room.

First, the timeline. The show aired from 1989 to 1998, so our math changes drastically. In the pilot, they’re supposedly hitting their early thirties. By the finale? They’ve crept into their late thirties—yikes, that’s a lot of coffee and soup without matching 401(k)s. Jerry Seinfeld was actually 35 in 1989, but his character, Jerry, feels perpetually 32. He’s still dating, still doing stand-up about airplane peanuts, and still has no furniture in his apartment. Classic arrested development.

George Costanza (Jason Alexander) was 30-ish in Season 1, but he acts like a petulant 14-year-old. Real age? He’s probably 34 by the time he fakes a job with Vandelay Industries. Elaine Benes (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) was the baby of the group—around 28 in the pilot, though she was actually 28 in real life. She ages gracefully, but let’s be honest, her J. Peterman wardrobe ages her up by about a decade. And Kramer? Michael Richards was 40 when the show started, but his character exists in a timeless vortex, fueled by Cuban cigars and chaotic energy.

Fun fact: The gang stays roughly the same age across the series because the writers ignored linear time. It’s a sitcom, not a documentary! So when you rewatch, just remember: They’re all perpetually in their mid-thirties, forever complaining about parking spots and the “second spitter.”

Here’s the uplifting truth: Age is just a number, especially in a world where you can still spend a whole afternoon dissecting a Soup Nazi’s rules. So grab a bowl of cereal, laugh at their antics, and know that no matter how old you are, there’s always time to find a good parking spot—or at least a good joke about one. Seinfeld may be forever stuck in the ’90s, but its timelessness? That’s the real victory.

'Seinfeld' Cast: Where Are They Now? DEMAK The Cast of Seinfeld Then and Now in 40 Photos